The MTGenWeb Project
The MTGenWeb Review Panel is responsible for selecting an outstanding county to receive the County of Excellence Award each month. The state is divided into 5 regions and one county will be nominated from each region each month. The 5 nominations will be sent to the Final Review Panel for determining the county to receive the award.
The State Coordinator will appoint the Review Panel Chair and the first members of the Review Panel. The Review Panel Chair will appoint subsequent members as needed. There is no limit on the number of members on the Review Panel. 5 members will be assigned regions and remaining members will be on stand-by to fill in as needed. A Final Review Panel of at least 3 members of the Review Panel will each review the nominated county sites and send the top 2 to the Review Panel Chair privately. The Chairperson will tally the votes and announce the County of Excellence on the mail list. In case of a tie, the Chairperson will review the tying sites and break the tie. Counties recieving the County of Excellence Award are ineligible for the award for a period of 6 months.
County web sites must be compliant with the following requirements to be eligible for the County of Excellence Award.
- Meet USGenWeb requirements
- The CC's name and email address is on the main page and the e-mail address is current.
- MTGenWeb is formatted correctly.
- The phrase GenWeb (without MT, US, Can, etc.) cannot be used anywhere on a website.
- The correct USGenWeb logo is on the front page.
- There is a link to the main MTGenWeb page on the front page.
- There is a link to to the main USGenWeb page on the front page.
- There is a link to a Query Page or Board.
- The site is focused on genealogy.
- Every page provides genealogy research. (No pages devoted to advertisements, no banner ads, no solicitations, etc.)
- The site has a lookup page for volunteers willing to do lookups in the county or at least have information on who to contact to volunteer.
Below is the explanation of points used in rating a web site. Sites are not compared against each other but are rated against an 'ideal'. Points are weighed towards encouraging the sites to have original records, transcriptions or abstracts on the site. It is likely that some sites will not have entries in every category. If there is nothing, a 0 is entered for that category. If there's something on the site that does not fall into a category, points are given in the Miscellaneous category.
The Selection Process
The counties have been divided into 5 regions (see the regions below) and a member of the Review Panel is assigned a region to review using the point system in the chart below. The top scoring site is then submitted to the Review Panel Chair, who collects all 5 submissions and sends the list to the Final Review Panel. Each member of the Final Review Panel reviews the sites using the same points system and submits the top 2 rated sites to the Review Panel Chair privately. The Chairperson tallies the "votes" and announces the County of Excellence.
County Contacts 0-5 Contact information for the county courthouse, libraries, museums, etc. Scans & Transcriptions 0-10 This includes all types of records that are scanned or transcribed. More points are given for records on the site than for links to records. County History 0-5 There are many types of county history. More points are given for more history Official Logo on Page 0-5 This is either 0 (no MTGenWeb logo) or 5 (has the logo) point category Last Update on Page 0-5 The more recent the Last Update date, the more points given Overall site search 0-5 Site search engine = 5 points Miscellaneous Content/Archives 0-10 This will include miscellaneous information that does not fit in any other category and active Archives links Presentation 0-10 Color, graphics, links working, page design, etc.
David Pitt, Jr
Lewis and Clark
Review Panel Chairperson:
Alternate Review Panel members:
Shirley Cullum, Bunny Freeman, & Christina Palmer
Final Review Panel members:
Shirley Cullum, State Coordinator
Christina Palmer, Assistant State Coordinator
Page Updated: 10 Oct 2013